Category Archives: BLOGS and WEBSITES

Blogs I read and cite from

Taleb, Hamel, Holling…and I

Is my idea of how to differ robustness from flexibility from agility from resilience – hallmark of my research ideas – in any way related to the ideas of Nassim Taleb, Crawford Stanley Holling and Gary Hamel? Well, Sinan Si Alhir certainly thinks so, on a blog post that he wrote back in 2013, when he explored Taleb’s concept of Fragility and Antifragility. Interesting…, so where do I fit in?

Surprise surprise

Having had an online published presence for almost 20 years now it should not come as a surprise to me that every now and then I stumble across myself in the unlikeliest of places for the unlikeliest of reasons. That said, by now, based from the bits and pieces I have seen here and there, I really should no longer be so surprised that my idea of how to differ robustness from flexibility from agility from resilience resonates with quite a number of people, including Si Alhir, in his blog post on Antifragile, Flexibility, Robust, Resilience, Agility, and Fragile.

The champion of Creative Destruction

Nassim Taleb is certainly no stranger on this blog. After all, in 2009 I did review The Six Mistakes Executives Make in Risk Management, an article he co-authored in the Harvard Business Review, and that was based on his book on Black Swans from 2007.  And although I read the book, I never reviewed it, but I remember that liked his ideas. His latest book “Antifragile: Things That Gain from Disorder” makes creative destruction a major point.

The father of Resilience Theory

CS Holling does not have a blog post here; in hindsight I guess he should have, because he is often recognized as one of the if not THE founding father of resilience theory, and resilience has been one of the more frequent topics on husdal.com, even more so after I turned resilience practitioner after being a resilience researcher. That said, since Holling’s main domain lies within ecology I never thought of his resilience as something that I would be particularly interested in. That is why he is only mentioned as a side note in a blog post on transportation resilience.

The Iconoclast

Gary Hamel is another almost unknown on this blog. He shouldn’t be, because bGary Hamel is one of the world’s most influential and iconoclastic business thinkers. In my small world he is mentioned in a comment on my blog post about the HBR guide to Managing External Risk, and I also mentioned him in my review of Lisa Välikangas book on The Resilient Organization, as her co-author in the article on The Quest for Resilience.

The Fantastic Four

So, in his blog post on Antifragile, Flexibility, Robust, Resilience, Agility, and Fragile Si Alhir features me and my definitions alongside those of Taleb, Hamel and Holling, and I must say that I do feel somewhat like being part of the Fantastic Four (pun intended):

However, the most interesting part of Si Alhirs blog post is not the side by side comparison, but a figure that integrates these concepts into one, and that shows how Taleb’s Fragility and Antifragility is a continuum that encloses or surrounds the other concepts.

 

I like this figure. In a previous blog post I explored Terje Aven’s definitions of vulnerability and resilience, and the notion that you can be generally resilient, but not generally vulnerable, only specifically vulnerable to the specific impact of a specific event relating to a specific risk. That notion now makes much more sense to me when I see fragility below vulnerability. This makes it clear that fragile is a general trait, while vulnerable is a specific trait.

A new way forward?

Taleb’s idea of antifragility is very intruiging, especially if seen the way that Si Alhir manages to put it into one figure that makes it all easy to understand and apply. That reminds me of a paper I wrote 10 years ago, in the early stages of what unfortunately did not manifest into a PhD. Anyway, in that paper – being a qualitative not a qualitative researcher – I took a liking of Giordano Bruno, the 16th century Italian philosopher. Bruno advocated the use of conceptualising, that is to think in terms of images, and he said that to think was to speculate with images. For people to understand science,  according to Bruno, it ought to be rich in images and concepts, but poor in formulas.

I think that is exactly what Taleb is trying to do, and I look forward to reading his book on Antifragility, and to see how his ideas fit my own ideas. Si Alhir seems to think they do. I consider that a compliment.

Related links

Related posts

Blog Review: Gold or Dust?

Striking gold in the blogosphere. Or was is just dust? This month’s blog is aptly titled “Gold or Dust” and is based on a true story, namely the academic journey of Charlie Newnham, who is studying for her MSc in Resilience at the University of Cranfield, UK. I wasn’t even aware that such a program existed and the blog chronicles her (almost daily) thoughts, her ideas and struggles as she comes to grip with what to write in her thesis topic, starting in December 2010, and now nearing completion. Is it dust? No, it’s pure gold. At least by my standards.
Continue reading

Blog Review: RiskCzar

How time flies. Another month has passed and it’s time for another blog review. This month it’s RISKCZAR’s BLOG by Trevor Levine, a blog that is based on his almost 20 years of experience in financial, operational and enterprise risk management (ERM), and process improvement. In other words,  a heavy-weight risk champion, but this is not a heavy-weight blog. It is a fun blog to read, for laughing more than learning, or rather “learning through laughing”. It is a blog that will make you smile. It is a blog that will make you realize that risk doesn’t have to be serious, because treating it too serious may make you end up in one of Trevor’s blog posts.

Trevor Levine

When presenting himself, Trevor writes this on his About page:

I am not a quant, an academic or an accountant but just a guy who likes writing about risk management in a way that anyone would understand. You will not see any Greek letters or equations in my posts because that side of risk management doesn’t interest me too much nor is that the audience I am trying to reach. I prefer the lighter side – while goofing on the misfortunes of those who failed to practice proactive risk management – just to make the point and make you laugh.

And indeed, that is exactly what his blog is about.

Blog Highlights

Here are some samples of what you can find on riskczar.com:

Recently he seems to be struck by “Harry Potter”-fever, because he has no less than four posts on Voldemort, including Voldemort as Risk Manager of the Year.

Lord Voldermort would make an excellent risk manager because when he identifies a risk, he assesses it and treats it immediately.

In the post Trevor comes up with four reasons why Voldemort makes and excellent risk manager. That said, I’m not sure I would want Voldemort as my own risk manager.

In Reputation Risk: Is Delta Airlines the Mel Gibson of Aviation he looks at some technically correct but perhaps morally questionable practices at Delta Airlines:

When Delta Airlines took over Northwest Airlines and their Detroit hub, they added Saudi Arabian Airlines to its SkyTeam Alliance of partner airlines. As a result of Saudi’s discriminatory policies, Delta will ban Jews and holders of Israeli passports from boarding flights to the Kingdom.

After this story came out, Delta of course had to defend itself by blogging: “We, like all international airlines, are required to comply with all applicable laws governing entry into every country we serve.”

I for one would like to know how Mel Gibson fits into this. What did I miss?

In The risk of driving: juice boxes and Howard Stern he pokes a bit fun at the ban of texting or phoning while driving, citing other distractions that may be far likely to cause a crash:

But after the phone risk is addressed, I think parents are still equally distracted by crying babies, infant siblings fighting in the back seats and the dreaded right-arm-reach-around to retrieve a juice box that recently fell that drips its red punch all over the beige floor mats when you squeeze it too hard.

As someone whose baby daughter was born 7 weeks ago I can only attest to that. Besides, holding and attempting to soothe a crying (read: raging) baby certainly adds to the risk of “crashing” something at home as well.

In Freshly ground typo risk he recalls the story of a “minor” typo in a cooking book:

An Australian publisher is reprinting 7,000 cookbooks over a recipe for pasta with “salt and freshly ground black people.”

Penguin Group Australia’s head of publishing, Bob Sessions, acknowledged the proofreader for the Pasta Bible should have picked up the error, but called it nothing more than a “silly mistake.”

Not sure how “silly” this is, but here in Norway the most famous brand for spices and herbs since 1952 was actually named “Black Boy” up until last fall, when they decided that while an established brand, it is perhaps not the best name for a brand these days. As I remember from my childhood, even the packaging featured the picture of a black boy, as can be seen in this article from a Norwegian newspaper who wrote about the name change. That said, their homepage URL is still blackboy.no.

Enterprise Risk Management

Trevor has a section devoted to the topic of enterprise risk mangement or ERM, where he lists 10 proofs of value of ERM, highlighting that while risk management is often seen as a mere expense, it does have a value. Interestingly, “resilience”, I topic I care about a lot was recently added as #10:

“While ERM is not a panacea for all the turmoil experienced in the markets in recent years, robust engagement by the board in enterprise risk oversight strengthens an organization’s resilience to significant risk exposures.” – COSO

I agree. Risk management and resilience definitely go hand in hand.

Conclusion

If you want to read about risk management in a fun and entertaining way, riskczar.com should be on your reading list. He’s been blogging since 2005, although regular posts first started in 2009, so there’s bunch of humorous posts for you to sift through.

Links

Related posts

Blog Review: Risk Containment

Another month has passed, and it’s time for another dive into the blogosphere. This month’s blog is a blog for anyone who works with or is exposed to risk, and it’s a blog full of personal insights, funny stories and profound wisdom. Slightly belated, due to the recent arrival of my baby daughter, which is why I am now a bit behind on my blogging let alone sleeping routines, this month’s blog review is a tribute to one of my most faithful Twitter followers and re-tweeters, Nicholas Hawtin of riskcontainment.com. Hardly a post on husdal.com goes by without Nicholas retweeting it, and often more than just once, thus bringing a steady flow of visitors to my blog. Nicholas, I owe you one, and this post is my Thank You for helping this blog reach its audience. Hopefully I can do the same for you, by promoting you on husdal.com.
Continue reading

Blog Review: Commitment Matters

It’s time for another blog review, and this month’s featured blog has been on my radar for quite some time. Looking at the date stamp on the original draft, it has actually been on my mind (or actually not) since 14 November 2009, that is 18 months almost to the day. It is Tim Cummins’ Commitment Matters. In Tim’s own words, it is a blog that will be of greatest interest to those who select, negotiate or manage relationships with trading partners – customers, suppliers, strategic alliances, teaming agreements or channels. A bold statement, but Tim holds what he promises. Tim surely knows his way around business relationships and how they can make or break a company and he stays true to his tagline, which reads Managing Trading Relationships in the Global Networked Economy. A blog for our time?

Continue reading

Blog Review: Oz’s Business Continuity Blog

This month’s blog review is not just a post, it is perhaps also an Easter Egg in disguise, considering the holiday season we’re in.  Truly, it is a great pleasure to present Oz’s Business Continuity Blog, written by by Andy Osborne, a consultant in business continuity and risk management from the UK. It is a blog as a blog should be, separated from the jargon and seriousness on Andy’s main business site and dedicated to reporting on Andy’s reflections on the everyday haps and mishaps that life brings him. It is a personal blog and it is a fun blog, but it never forgets its main goal: to spread life’s own lessons in business continuity and risk management.

Continue reading

Blog Review: The SCRMBlog

It’s Friday, and there hasn’t be a blog review for a long time, so perhaps it’s time to resurrect the “supply chain blogs of note” series that some time ago I said I would do every month, but have sadly neglected. My featured blog this month is the SCRMBlog by Daniel Stengel, as it happens perhaps my fiercest competitor in the supply chain risk blogging scene, if there indeed is such a scene. Daniel’s blog has existed for not more than a little over a year, but he has already made considerable impact, and I often find him reviewing papers I haven’t heard of yet, or worse, have heard of and put on my to-do list, but not yet blogged about, meaning that he beat me to the finish line. Well, Daniel, this post is for you.

Continue reading

Supply Chain Risk Insights

Today’s title serves two purposes: Firstly, it describes what I take back from the ISCRiM 2010 seminar I attended this week, where I had the chance to meet a small selection of who’s who in supply chain risk research. Secondly, it is the name of a fascinating new website I learned of at the seminar. Set up by Zurich Insurance, the website is aimed at helping senior managers and directors in finance, supply chain, operations and risk develop a deeper understanding of the tactical considerations and strategic approaches to minimize impacts of disruptions to the supply chain. And this is a site that is definitely worth having in your bookmarks.

Continue reading

Blog Review: Contemplating…Ken Simpson

It’s Friday, and I think I’m going to make Fridays a day for blog reviews and other “lighter” and “casual” subjects. Today’s blog is Ken Simpson’s Contemplating… blog, a rather recent addition to the business continuity blogging world – the first post is dated November 20th this year. Actually it’s not so much about just business continuity, but about resilience, a topic I have a strong inclination towards, next to supply chain risk. Ken’s blog is a must read for the business continuity professional seeking a wider perspective on what resilience actually means.
Continue reading

The @risk Blog

It is always nice to find blogs on supply chain risk written by a professional with extensive knowledge of the field he is covering. Kevin Cornish‘s @risk blog is such a blog. Judging by the list of tags in his sidebar there is very little that escapes his watchful eye, with topics touching upon anything ranging from employee absentism, food safety, to the more obvious: risk mitigation and supplier risk. There is such a wealth of information I am not sure where to begin.

Continue reading

Blog Review: The Kinaxis Blog

I said in my post on Bob Ferrari’s blog Supply Chain Matters that I was going to resurrect my previous habit of presenting and reviewing supply chain risk blogs. A promise is a promise, so here is a high-quality blog for you, the Kinaxis Blog, or as they put it themselves: The 21st Century Supply Chain. And is it a correct tagline? Yes, I think so. But is there anything supply chain risk? Oh yes, most definitely so, very much indeed. Actually, I should have known, because no less than two days ago I was referring to an interview with Gary Lynch, when reviewing his latest book, The Single Point of Failure.

Continue reading

Blog Review: Supply Chain Matters

Today I am resurrecting a long neglected task, my review of selected blogs and websites that deal with supply chain risk and related issues. It is almost a year since last time a blog was added here, and one of the reasons why I haven’t done so is that a) this blog has turned its attention towards literature reviews as the main focus, and b) there are simply too many blogs to mention them all. Noneless, today I’m resuming my reviews,  and the first one out is Bob Ferrari’s Supply Chain Matters blog.

Continue reading

Agile Business Continuity

The other day I came across a new term: Agile Business Continuity, on the blog of Paul James, agilecontinuity.org. The coupling of the term agile with business continuity aroused my curiosity and I decided to dig deeper into what this blog was really about. I discovered that was a blog that is well worth reading and I think that the word agile really captures the essence of what business continuity management (BCM) is about in the first place and I will explain why I think so.

Continue reading

Risky Thinking

This is a reciprocal gesture towards Michael Z. Bell, who is kind enough to list me in the blogroll on his Risky Thinking blog, as I just found out the other day. Michael is a Business Continuity consultant currently based in Ottawa, Canada, and his business website (and blog) presents current information and opinions on business continuity, disaster recovery, risk assessment, and business impact analysis. riskythinking.com contains many articles on Business Continuity and Risk Management. Obviously I cannot make a post on my blog about every website that lists me one way or the other, but this one of the more interesting websites I have seen lately.

Continue reading

The Supply Chain Network Project

Have you come across the Supply Chain Network or SCN? Not yet? Do you want to keep in touch with all aspects of the global supply chain network? SCN is a network of people, a network of ideas and information, a means for designing, building, improving and managing your physical network and a source for services to facilitate your network. The contributors on write about products and services they believe are unique, different and can add value to the supply chain.

Continue reading

Risk Central

Risk Central is a private and personal initiative and web portal started by Roberto Pinto, assistant professor and Ph.D student at the University of Bergamo, Department of Industrial Engineering – with the aim at collecting and share with other interested people news, facts, stories, events, experiences, discussions and whatever could be related to Risk Management, Business Continuity Management, Vulnerability Management, Resilient Enterprise and related topics.

Continue reading