A conceptual framework for supply chain vulnerability

Today’s article is one of the earlier works on supply chain vulnerability, published in 2000. A conceptual framework for the analysis of vulnerability in supply chains by Göran Svensson uses the Swedish car manufacturer Volvo as grounds for establishing his theoretical framework. This is the first of two papers on the same topic; this paper deals particularly with the inbound supply chain. A second paper, which I will review tomorrow, deals both with inbound and outbound logistics.

Two dimensions

Separating the chaff from the wheat and diving straight into the essence of the paper, Svensson aligns his framework along two dimensions, categories of disturbance and sources of disturbance. He then divides the categories into either quantitative or qualitative disturbances. Sources of disturbance are either atomistic (direct) or holistic (indirect).

Categories of disturbance

Disturbances are either quantitative or qualitative.



Disturbances are quantitative if they lead to a lack of materials or components. Causes for such disturbances are usually a breakdown in inbound logistics, e.g. delays in inbound transport due to accidents, bad weather or any other reason for a “no-show” of components or materials.

Disturbances are qualitative if they lead to defects in components or materials. Causes are events that lead to poor paint, uneven surfaces, measurement errors or any other kind of malfunctional or non-fitting components or materials.

Sources of disturbance

The supply chain of incoming materials and components can be seen form a narrow or a wide perspective. The narrow or atomistic vulnerability perspective focuses on the immediate cause, and is applicable if the disturbance has its source and impact limited to a small part of the supply chain, i.e. immediate cause and immediate impact and immediate remedy. The wide or holistic vulnerability perspective is applicable if the disturbance has a cause outside the immediate event, i.e. in the upstream supply chain, and if the event impacts the supply chain further downstream.

The framework matrix

Framework for Supply Chain Vulnerability Analysis

Svensson (2000): Framework for Supply Chain Vulnerability Analysis

Conclusion

Svensson argues that, based on his empirical findings, the two dimensions (sources and categories of disturbance) are highly valid, reliable and universally applicable, and I am am inclined to second his notion. Indeed, it is a useful and practical approach. One perspective is lacking though, and that is the outbound logistics flow.

This framework looks exclusively at the inbound flow, and although the holistic approach does acknowledge a downstream impact, this impact is not further analyzed. However, in a second paper, following up on this research, Svensson has incorporated both inbound and outbound flow, and that will be the topic for tomorrow’s post.

Reference:

Svensson, G. (2000). A conceptual framework for the analysis of vulnerability in supply chains International Journal of Physical Distribution & Logistics Management, 30 (9), 731-750 DOI: 10.1108/09600030010351444

Links

Related

Posted in ARTICLES and PAPERS
Tags: , , , ,

ARTICLES and PAPERS
Popular in SC Resilience
What are the Top of the Pops of Supply Chain Resilience papers? That could be the fitting title for [...]
Perspectives on risk management in supply chains
Today's article is actually not an article on it's own, but an editorial to a special 2009 issue of [...]
BOOKS and BOOK CHAPTERS
Book Review: Transportation GIS
This book showcases many examples of how GIS can be applied in the field of transportation using Arc[...]
Book Review: Virtual Teams
This is another post resulting from my literature review when researching background material for my[...]
REPORTS and WHITEPAPERS
Supply Chain and Transport Risk
In our interconnected world, safety, reliability and efficiency can only be secured through collabor[...]
Vulnerable or valuable supply chain?
More than a year old now, but still holding not so few words of wisdom is the Pricewaterhouse Cooper[...]